alleigha botner

Alleigha Botner (24) is an Ohio-based worship leader and former church intern who became a central figure in the 2026 murder trial of former American Idol contestant Caleb Flynn.

Key details regarding her involvement include:

• Relationship with Caleb Flynn: Botner testified that she met Flynn while she was an intern at the Christian Life Center in Dayton, Ohio, where Flynn was also involved in the worship ministry. She stated that their relationship turned sexual in March 2024 and lasted approximately a year and a half.
• Testimony: During the trial for the murder of Flynn’s wife, Ashley Flynn, Botner provided testimony detailing their affair. She alleged that Flynn frequently disparaged his wife, expressed hatred toward her, and discussed wanting her dead. Botner also testified that she had initially lied to FBI agents about the nature of her relationship with Flynn before later revealing the truth.
• Church Career: Botner served as a worship leader at the Christian Life Center. Following Flynn's arrest for the murder of his wife, she resigned from her position at the church.
• Legal Status: Botner has not been charged with any crimes in connection to the case. She was identified as a witness for the prosecution.